Staff | Report
A fourth year psychology student was blocked by IGNITE’s official Instagram account on Thursday for what they called “spam” after several weeks of criticizing the student union for inaction on several issues.
The University of Guelph-Humber student, who co-founded the Pre-Med Society on campus, Hannah Derue, said that she made several comments criticizing IGNITE’s efforts largely around the Student Choice Initiative.
“You have done nothing to inspire the confidence or voluntary dollars of the students you’re looking to represent,” she wrote in one comment on a Feb. 5 post from IGNITE about a protest they attended.
“Here’s where our student government’s priorities are as we wrap up the last semester of mandatory ancillary fees. Good luck with convincing student(s) to find your meme account in the fall,” she respond on another post that depicted a popular creature from the Harry Potter movies.
These and other comments were removed after the student union blocked her account. A video posted by Derue in her Instagram Story shows how when she is logged out she can access the @ShareIGNITE page but when she logs in, she is unable to.
In a response to a tweet from Derue, IGNITE said she was blocked because her account was “used to spam our Instagram with the same comment on 24 posts, and so we blocked it” and invited her to contact their media coordinator if she wants to have it unblocked.
Hey Hannah, your account was used to spam our Instagram with the same comment on 24 posts, and so we blocked it. If this was done in error or if you have a reason why you'd like us to reconsider, reach out to our Digital Media Coordinator, Stephen Wong. https://t.co/6fpsr5qpQN— IGNITE (@ShareIGNITE) April 25, 2019
Derue replied to IGNITE’s response with a video showing what appeared to be a “bot account” for a business selling fruit on a Valentine’s Day-themed post, asking: “so IGNITE takes down my comments and blocks me but leaves spam messages from advertisers and bot accounts?”
There has not yet been a response from the student union to Derue’s reply.
“IGNITE should be ashamed of itself for running on a platform of transparency and blocking and deleting comments from those who dissent,” Derue told The Avro Post, referencing the student union’s statements saying they are transparent.
“They do not operate with democratic principles in mind and censor outside opinions. This will be reflected as students vote with their wallets this fall.”
There is no precedent known by The Avro Post for the student union to block an individual student. Other students have made some comments critical of IGNITE or have supported Derue’s comment but do not appear to have been blocked.
An investigation by The Avro Post to be published later this week found that IGNITE has posted 28 memes — humorous images usually made funny the text superimposed on them — since Jan. 17 when changes to student financial life were announced.
The Avro Post has reached out for comment from the executive director and president of IGNITE. The student union, however, has not responded to a formal request for comment since August 2018.
Image of IGNITE from The Avro Post.
Disclaimer: Hannah Derue is the partner of the editor-in-chief of The Avro Post but this story was written without influence and has been independently written and reviewed for accuracy and impartial reporting. ■
IGNITE Board to meet again in a hidden location
The student union has hidden exact locations since September.
IGNITE’s Board of Directors, made up of elected student representatives, will be meeting on Wednesday evening at the University of Guelph-Humber, according to a schedule posted earlier this year by the student union, but no exact location or time has been made public.
The Board meeting locations were removed by the student union in September after paid staff blocked a reporter from The Avro Post from entering that month’s gathering of directors, a meeting that later turned out to be of major significance.
The Avro Post attempted to find the meeting in October but was unsuccessful. According to the IGNITE bylaws, the directors have to hold a majority vote to kick a student from the meeting, including student journalists. They are also required to post the meetings publicly.
However, IGNITE has rules currently on its Governance webpage that instruct students, who are classified as members of the union, to reach out to the executive director to obtain access to the meetings, bending the rules of their own bylaws.
If the meeting is indeed held in the University of Guelph-Humber, the typical location for the Board to gather is the conference room found by the entrance doors to the university in the Atrium. ■
Briefing: Everything IGNITE since September
100 words, 700 words and point-form.
Welcome to the Briefing, a new type of article that breaks down a story into a 100 word version, a 700 full-length edition and a point form analysis.
This Briefing is on everything going on with the governance of IGNITE, the student union for Humber College and the University of Guelph-Humber, since the beginning of the student year.
IGNITE is looking to make several changes to how the student union works.
All of these changes will need majority approval from students at a January Special Meeting of the Members. They were previously approved by the Board of Directors in September.
The proposed bylaw amendments give the Board more unilateral power and end president and vice president elections.
The Board has been hiding the location of their meetings, breaking its own bylaws that specify that exact times and locations are to be posted publicly.
IGNITE recently cut off The Avro Post from press briefings, interviews and all media requests.
IGNITE has proposed several bylaw amendments to how its governance and operations function. Some of these changes have precedent elsewhere but many are uncommon for a student union.
All of these changes will need majority approval from students at a January Special Meeting of the Members, a meeting that any student can attend and have a vote on the changes as a unified package, but not individual amendments.
These amendments were previously approved by the Board of Directors in September. The meeting minutes only give the “highlights” of the amendments so it may not be all of the proposed changes, however.
The most outwardly noticeable change for students at Humber College and the University of Guelph-Humber will be the end of executive elections.
The executive team is made up of the president, who represents all IGNITE members and each vice president, each representing either North Campus, Lakeshore or Guelph-Humber.
Another change that the Board wants to bring about is the ability for their decisions to come into effect immediately after majority approval at a meeting. However, an item approved will still need later approval at a meeting of the members.
If the members — all voting students — vote against the changes at the Special Meeting of the Members, it is unclear if the decision is applied retroactively or if the Board’s decision is simply repealed from the bylaws.
Also, if students are unable to find the Board meetings and minutes are only posted a month later after they are approved at the next Board meeting, students would be unaware for at least 30 days that a bylaw had changed.
The Board did not post the meeting minutes from the May or September meetings until long after the October Board meeting, which, despite efforts from The Avro Post to find it, was hidden.
If The Post was able to enter the Board meeting in September instead of being told to leave in a unilateral move by a staff member, then this publication would have been able to report that these bylaws were passed by the directors.
There were some new items also passed by the Board and up for consideration by students in January including, but not limited to, new classifications of IGNITE membership, document execution being under the control of the executive director and a vaguely worded amendment specifying that “president term will be used for [B]oard chairperson”.
The new classifications come about because of the Student Choice Initiative and was expected.
The top classification is “Full-Time Enhanced Members”, which appear to be those that opt-in to IGNITE fees, though there is no specification for those that only opt-in to some.
“Full-Time Members” and “Part-Time Members” are those who pay only the mandatory ancillary fees. All three classifications are official members of IGNITE and so it is understood they will be able to still vote in elections and at special meetings.
It is unclear exactly what “executive documents being overseen by the executive director” means as an amendment but The Avro Post has reached out for comment from IGNITE for clarification.
Another hard-to-understand change is the “president term” being used for the Board chairperson. It is not clear via the meeting minutes whether that means the president’s term in regards to time or the terminology of “president” being applied to the chairperson.
Currently, the Board directors start and end their term at the same time as the executives so it would seem unusual for new amendments to specify that just the chair would have the same term timewise as the president.
It seems more likely that the chairperson position itself could be renamed to “president” to signify the Board’s importance from the student perspective, a goal that Executive Director Ercole Perrone and other officials have said they have committed to in the coming months.
These items will be flushed out in more detail at the Special Meeting of the Member and potentially press briefings that The Post will no longer have access to due to being cut off by IGNITE on Oct. 15 from press briefings, elected student representatives and all other media requests.
President Monica Khosla explained the main reason for this was because The Post inaccurately reported that the executive director, Perrone, said that IGNITE eventually wants to cut Board of Directors meetings off entirely from students that are members.
The Avro Post stands by the reporting as accurate. However, there is no plan in place at this time in the set of bylaw amendments headed to the special meeting in January to enact such a change.
Various points on the incoming bylaws:
- Ending executive elections: Not unprecedented but definitely not common for student unions in Ontario. IGNITE says it means “higher quality” executives.
- Unilateral Board decisions: Also not unprecedented and appears to be utilized by other student unions. However, an ex-president of another student union said that changing bylaws are typically a move ratified by an AGM.
- To note: Amendments will still be ratified by a meeting of the members — which are all students — with this proposal.
All these changes will be passed or not passed at a Special Meeting of the Members expected for mid- to late-January. If they are passed, they will come into effect, likely immediately.
If not, it is unclear if there will be need to be urgent Board action to come up with new proposals for the Annual General Meeting usually held near the end of the winter semester. ■
IGNITE holding financial planning event
The event is part of the ‘Lunch & Learn’ series.
IGNITE is holding a free event focused on financial planning featuring Rob Carrick of The Globe and Mail.
The event, called ‘How to Not Move Back in With Your Parents”, will run on Nov. 13 from 12:30 to 2:30 p.m. and students can register via Eventbrite.
The first 25 students to arrive will recieve a free copy of Carrick’s book of the same name as the event.
The event is part of the “Lunch & Learn” series on how to be an adult presented by IGNITE, that focuses on financial independence. ■
‘The Mandalorian’: Chapter 2 review
1x02 of 'The Mandalorian'.
Humber Galleries calling for artwork
Humber Galleries aims to inspire.
Review: ‘Charlie’s Angels’
New girls, same action.
Undermanned Raptors win in Portland
The Toronto Raptors defeated the Portland Trail Blazers 114-106 on Wednesday.
Humber Galleries calling for artwork
Humber Galleries hopes to inspire current students and alumni to submit artwork.
Campus2 months ago
Federal debate at University of Guelph scrapped over PPC policies
Campus4 months ago
First Year Experience launches blog to help students
Security1 year ago
FBI Says Restart Your Router!
Canada Votes 20191 month ago
Johnson-Figueredo: No, a gun ban will not curb violence
Campus4 months ago
Humber College outlines how student fees will work
Campus2 weeks ago
Johnson-Figueredo: IGNITE no longer represents us, the students
Campus3 months ago
MPP calls for education minister to admit drop in enrolment
Style2 years ago
30 student discounts every student needs